200207
191128

Do you support involuntary custodial care for people ­on the street with substance abuse and mental illness?

Poll: Involuntary custody

Victoria Police Chief Del Manak says he supports ­involuntary custodial care for people ­struggling with substance abuse and mental illness who are at high risk of harming ­others, as recommended by a health researcher and former deputy police chief this week.

“We have to stop kidding ­ourselves. It’s not working.

“When are we going to admit that some people just can’t stop and no amount of hoping is going to change that?” Manak said ­Friday.

“As a police chief, I’ve strongly advocated for enhanced care for addicted and mentally ill people for a number of years. What we need are treatment facilities to respond to the needs and legislation to treat people involuntarily.”

The chief’s comments come in the wake of a report commissioned by B.C.’s attorney general and public safety minister to address concerns about repeat offenders and the increase in random, violent-stranger attacks.

An executive summary and recommendations by health researcher Amanda Butler and former Vancouver deputy police chief Doug LePard were released by the government Wednesday. Their full 150-page report is expected later this month.

Manak said he welcomes the report and its recommendations. “When it comes to involuntary custodial care, we don’t want to have that discussion. We’re afraid of that discussion. … Yet we continue to fail individuals who so desperately need something to help them live their daily lives.”

Involuntary custodial care would only be for the small number of people who continue to fall through the cracks, he said, and should only be considered on a case-by-case basis where mental-health professionals have conducted proper assessments to determine that an individual cannot control their actions and is a significant risk for anti-social, violent behaviour.

Read more

Have an opinion? Send it to [email protected]



Previous Polls

November 24, 2022 - 10351 votes
Have you had a flu shot this year?

Yes: 5197
No: 5154

November 23, 2022 - 6726 votes
Will you make a charitable donation this Christmas?

Yes: 3867
No: 2241
Unsure: 618

November 22, 2022 - 6894 votes
Should provinces use the notwithstanding clause to end labour disputes?

Yes: 1989
No: 4172
Unsure: 733

November 21, 2022 - 8224 votes
Do you feel safe using ATMs in the evening in your community?

Yes: 2814
No: 4728
Unsure: 682

November 19, 2022 - 13733 votes
If you found a large amount of money on the sidewalk, would you turn it in?

Yes: 7923
No: 3873
Unsure: 1937



Previous Poll Results

Have you had a flu shot this year?

Total Votes:  10352
Yes: 
50.21%
No: 
49.79%

» Previous Polls

Have an idea for a poll question?
Email us [email protected]


199158
202355
199701
204535