What does carbon tax 'about-face' say about B.C. government's climate action plans?

Photo: Contributed

Kelowna Mission MLA Renee Merrifield

B.C. Premier David Eby’s recent announcement to exempt all but the largest emitters from the provincial carbon tax (if the federal government drops its requirement that provinces have a carbon tax) marks a stunning reversal of one of the NDP's core policies.

For years, the NDP government championed the carbon tax as a critical tool to reduce emissions and one of the key parts of their CleanBC plan, despite widespread concerns over its impact on families, small businesses, and our provincial economy.

Now, in what appears to be an attempt to soften the blow of an affordability crisis it helped create, the government is walking back its commitment to this policy. But the question remains: Why did it take so long, and is this about-face real?

Since its introduction (in 2008 by the former Liberal government of then-premier Gordon Campbell), the carbon tax has placed a disproportionate burden on ordinary British Columbians. Previous government’s attempted to ease that burden by making the carbon tax “revenue neutral.” The promise of a revenue-neutral carbon tax quickly fell by the wayside under the current government and instead, the carbon tax became a growing source of government revenue, with no meaningful reduction in emissions to justify the growing tax burden.

David Eby’s recent announcement that he will now exempt everyone except large industrial emitters from the carbon tax is a clear about-face. It took me by surprise.

For years, the NDP framed the carbon tax as an essential measure that everyone had to bear for the good of the planet. Now, faced with increasing pressure from families and businesses struggling under the weight of inflation and rising fuel costs, the government has finally admitted this policy has placed an unfair burden on everyday people.

The timing of this shift is certainly convenient for the NDP, but it raises important questions about its long-term vision for British Columbia’s economy and environment. What does the reversal say about the NDP’s commitment to fighting climate change? And what does it mean for the average British Columbian who has been footing the bill for years, only to see the government change course at the eleventh hour?

Many of the people that I speak to in Kelowna are very concerned about climate change, and while there is a mixture of opinions on causes and solutions, they want a government that has a credible plan.

In my view, removing the carbon tax for most British Columbians is a step in the right direction, however British Columbia deserves better than reactive policy changes driven by political expediency. We need a government that will prioritize the needs of British Columbians while pursuing practical, innovative solutions to environmental challenges.

We should be investing in technology and incentivizing innovation in green energy. There’s a way forward that protects both our environment and our economy, but it requires thoughtful leadership, not last-minute political maneuvers.

My two questions for you this week are:

1) Do you agree with scrapping B.C.’s carbon tax? Why or why not?

2) What kinds of climate action plans would you like to see take its place?

I have loved every email you have written me, and read them all. Please email me at [email protected] or call my office at 250-712-3620.

Renee Merrifield is the BC United MLA for Kelowna-Mission.

This article is written by or on behalf of an outsourced columnist and does not necessarily reflect the views of Castanet.