Going 'green' has a cost

From John Pettimore, a retired Canadian miner, and Mining Watch Canada, here are some numbers and facts to consider next time someone tells you electric vehicles are "green".

• There are currently 1.5 billion internal combustion vehicles in the world.

• Each 1,000 pound EV battery requires the mining of 90,000 pounds of ore, requiring the energy consumption equivalent to 100 barrels of oil - for a battery that can store the equivalent energy of one barrel of oil.

• Purifying one tonne of rare earth metal requires 200 cubic meters (44,000 gallons) of water, which then become polluted with acids and heavy metals.

• 18,000 pounds of ore are required to produce two pounds of vanadium.

• 35,000 pounds of ore are required for two pounds of cerium.

• 110,000 pounds of ore are required for two pounds of gallium.

• 2,600,000 pounds of ore are required for 2 pounds of lutecium.

These are all metals (granted sometimes in small amounts) required for EV batteries and/or solar panels.

Mankind already uses two billion tonnes of metals every year, equivalent to 500 Eiffel Towers every day.

One-fifth of China's arable land (land that is suitable for growing plants and/or crops) is already polluted due to mining.

If we were to mine all of the metals required for the "green industry", it would adversely impact 35% of the world's land area, not including Antarctica.

Lloyd Vinish, Kelowna

More Letters to the editor



The opinions expressed here are strictly those of the author. Castanet does not in any way warrant the information presented.

Visit our discussion forum
for these and other issues.

Previous Stories