Saturday, April 19th-0.7°C

Fire protection in the city

Ontario Man wrote:  Has nobody heard of mutual aid between departments? The priority is to put the fire out and forget about stupid politics, whose area, who should go, etc.we would never let that happen in our rural areas..
I guess things are different in Ontario.  MUTUAL AID here in BC does indeed refer to one (or more) fire departments helping out another when the first hasn't enough equipment or manpower to handle a situation  WITHIN ONE'S FIRE COVERAGE BOUNDARIES.
The problem lies in the fact that the premises in question was situated OUTSIDE ANY EXISTING FIRE DEPARTMENT(Municipal) Boundaries.  Fire departments don't simply "exist" but are set up and paid for to provide fire coverage to the people, businesses and properties  WITHIN certain Town, Municipal, City,  or Regional District boundaries.
Those that choose to purchase property or build outside such covered areas of course will save money on taxes (which pay for the Fire Services and others) but they must realize that if they aren't paying for a service and aren't living in a recognized Fire District, they shouldn't expect that  FireCrews/equipment  will mount up and head out of their "home" areas to provide coverage to those outside the boundaries. As a nearby example, several residents have built very expensive homes at the southern end of Lakeshore Road on the east side of the Lake. 

These properties are outside the boundaries of the City of Kelowna.  These folks don't have Fire Department coverage and I'm sure they must pay much higher FIRE Insurance premiums there (if they can get any Fire Insurance at all..)  Its my understanding that they as a group have petitioned Kelowna to be covered for Fire Services but that Kelowna declined their request.
So, I question just how far "out of town" do these writers expect that the Fire Crews should respond ?   A mile or so?  Five miles, ten miles, 50 miles ?  The thing is, there is NO provision for providing Fire coverage OUTSIDE the boundaries.
Similarly, no other taxpayer funded Municipal services  (sewer, water, garbage collection etc) are provided  free of charge to others living outside the boundaries and that is how it should be..
Lets say the Fire Department did head out there and the home still burned down.. or, what if  someone or a firefighter got injured or a home in Peachland burned while Peachland's crews were "out of town".  Who gets sued for that ? 
Reality dictates:
WANT FIRE COVERAGE ?  Live "in town"..   Live out of town..No Fire Department,  sorry, that's just how it is. Its not up to the local Fire Chief, Captain or Lieutenant to decide to make his own rules and leave town.  He and his men are there to cover THEIR town, city (etc) only.

Alan Sanderson

Read more Letters to the editor

Recent Trending

Email us your letter!
  • We must have your full names for publication with your letter. If you wish to publish anonymously try our discussion forums.
  • Please keep letters to 250 words or less.
  • We reserve the right to edit letters for accuracy, brevity, grammar, punctuation and clarity.
  • Due to space constraints, we can not publish all letters sent to us.
  • We also accept letters in the form of MP3 audio files and WMV, AVI, MOV, FLV or YouTube video files. Keep your presentations to less than two minutes in duration.
  • All emails received become property of Castanet Media Ltd. subject for publication.

  • Email your letters for publication to
    [email protected]


    The opinions expressed here are strictly those of the author. Castanet does not in any way warrant the information presented.

    Visit our discussion forum
    for these and other issues.

    Previous Stories