Thursday, April 24th7.8°C
21633
20874

Government kicks tires on other jets

A questionnaire meant to gauge what options exist to replace the air force's aging CF-18 fighters has landed on the desks of aerospace companies in North America and Europe.

The 15-page survey is considered the first step in evaluating whether the Conservative government should bail out of its planned, and controversial, F-35 stealth fighter deal with U.S. defence giant Lockheed Martin.

It is considered a "draft" and asks potential rivals to outline the capabilities of their aircraft, but does not request detailed cost information.

That will come in a follow-up survey next month. It also leaves the door open for aerospace companies to give suggestions on what questions the government might have missed, or what technical aspects should be explored.

Lockheed Martin has been asked to fill out the survey along with other potential bidders including: U.S-based Boeing with its Super Hornet; EADS Eurofighter, also known as the Typhoon; Dassault, which is selling its French-built Rafale; and the Saab-manufactured Gripen from Sweden.

The request for information falls short of the demand by critics and the opposition to open the program up to a full-fledged competition, but is part of the government's promise to review all of the potential options to replace the CF-18s.

Last spring, in a scathing report, Auditor General Michael Ferguson accused National Defence and Public Works of hiding the full cost the F-35 Lightning and not following the proper procedures.

The government said in 2010 that it intended buy the stealth fighter, stating it was the best and "only" option to replace the current fleet.

But since the auditor's report, which caused a storm of political and public criticism, the government committed to reviewing other options through a committee of independent experts.

The review is expected to shed light on whether the Conservatives will end up sticking with the F-35, or abandon it in favour of a full-on competition.

A spokesman for EADS acknowledged it had received the survey and would respond.

"The Eurofighter consortium has had communication with Canada and will assist them whenever possible," Theodor Benien said in an email.

But a long-time critic of the F-35 program says there is deep skepticism in the defence community about the path the government has taken.

Each aircraft maker has secret information on the capabilities of their aircraft, something they would be reluctant to share without the guarantee of a full competition, said Alan Williams, a former senior defence bureaucrat.

"You're not going to get the kind of specific, detailed technical requirements through a questionnaire," Williams said.

"My advice is, if they're serious, do the right thing the right way."

The Canadian Press
How does this story make you feel? (68 total votes)
Castanet MoodMeter
Amused
1.5%
Annoyed
20.6%
Happy
47.1%
Sad
2.9%
Disappointed
1.5%
Skeptical
26.5%


Read more Canada News

21672


Recent Trending





21502


19887

21584



Canada Quick Links Canada Discussion Forum
Government of Canada
Service Canada
Canada Revenue Agency
Statistics Canada
Strategis
Canada Post
Environment Canada



Member of BC Press Council


21188