Ferry in fatal sinking in 'best condition'

The passenger ferry that sank off the coast of British Columbia seven years ago, leaving two passengers missing, had recently returned to service after five months of upgrades and was probably in the best condition of its life, a crew member's criminal negligence trial heard Monday.

Navigating officer Karl Lilgert is on trial for the deaths of Gerald Foisy and Shirley Rosette, who vanished when the Queen of the North sank in March 2006 and were presumed drowned.

The Queen of the North was taken out of service in October 2005 for scheduled upgrades, which included installing a new radar system, a senior mariner with BC Ferries testified.

Ross Bowen, who has worked on BC Ferries' northern routes for more than 30 years, told the court he was with the ship during those upgrades. He was also involved in subsequent sea trials and helped sail the vessel back to the start of its route on the northern end of Vancouver Island once the work was complete.

"The vessel operated properly," Bowen testified. "I don't recall any issues that were outstanding from the sea trials."

At the time, Bowen was a senior officer on the Queen of the North and worked on a separate watch from Lilgert. Crews were divided into two watches, each working two weeks at a time and then spending two weeks off.

The Queen of the North returned to service at the beginning of March, and Bowen's watch operated the vessel until Lilgert's watch took over on March 15. During those first two weeks, Bowen said the vessel appeared to be in excellent shape.

"What condition was the Queen of the North in?" asked Crown counsel Robert Wright.

"I personally felt that it was in the best condition that we ever had it," Bowen replied.

"How was the bridge equipment working at that time?" asked Wright.

"Everything was working very well," replied Bowen.

The defence has suggested unreliable navigation equipment, along with poor weather and inadequate BC Ferries policies, contributed to the sinking.

The Crown argues Lilgert failed in his duties to keep the ship on course as it sailed toward a large island after missing a crucial turn.

The upgrades that took place in late 2005 and early 2006 included a new radar system and a new gyro compass, which measures true north instead of magnetic north, the court heard. There was also other work done in the bridge, such as the installation of an additional autopilot switch.

Transport Canada officials inspected the ferry before it returned to service and concluded it was seaworthy, said Bowen.

Those efforts saved 99 passengers and crew. Foisy and Rosette were never seen again.

Lilgert has pleaded not guilty to two counts of criminal negligence causing death. His trial, before a jury, is expected to last up to six months.

More Canada News

Parliament Hill
Parliament Hill Webcam
Recent Trending
Okanagan Oldies
Castanet Proud Member of RTNDA Canada