Tory's torture directive draws fire
Aug 27, 2012 / 3:22 pm
The Conservatives are condoning immoral abuses, and flouting the law, by allowing RCMP and Canada Border Services officers to use information obtained through torture, say opposition MPs.
Newly disclosed records show Public Safety Minister Vic Toews quietly issued the instructions to the Mounties and the border agency last September after giving nearly identical orders to Canada's spy service.
The government directives, released under the Access to Information Act, state that protection of life and property are the chief considerations when deciding on the use of information that may have been extracted through torture.
They also outline instructions for deciding whether to share information when there is a "substantial risk" that doing so might result in someone in custody being abused.
The Privy Council Office did not respond to questions Monday as to whether other ministers had issued similar directives.
Civil liberties and human rights organizations have condemned the federal approach, saying it will simply invite cellblock abuses by rogue foreign regimes.
NDP public safety critic Randall Garrison said Monday the federal directives directly contradict Canada's legal obligations under the Convention Against Torture to shun mistreatment of prisoners.
"When you talk about things having a slippery slope, torture probably has the slipperiest slope of them all internationally," said Garrison, who worked with Amnesty International in 2002 on educating police officers in Afghanistan about human rights.
Interim Liberal Leader Bob Rae called the latest directives "quite shocking."
"I think it's a truly disgraceful moment in Canadian public policy, and I think its sets us back a very long way."
In written replies this summer to members of the public, Toews said that while the government does not approve of or engage in torture, it will not abide "dithering" when safety is threatened.
"You may have heard my political opponents take the position that under no circumstances, even in a situation where thousands of lives could be at risk, should certain information that came into the possession of Canadian officials be used to save lives," Toews wrote in two letters obtained by The Canadian Press.
"Let me be perfectly clear: Canada does not condone torture and we certainly do not engage in it. It is a fundamentally abhorrent practice that runs directly contrary to Canada's reputation as a protector of human rights.
"What we also do not condone is dithering in the face of threats to the lives of Canadians."
Toews says information that may have come from torture "would not be used in prosecutions" but in "an operational context" to protect Canadian life and property.
Read more Canada News
- Astronaut adjusting to 'earthling' life
- Elijah Harper's body will lie in state
- Spectator killed during Jeep demo
- Panda exhibit opens at Toronto Zoo
- Fishermen missing off NB coast
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford cancels show
- Family found unconscious in fire
- Saskatchewan zombies
- Sen. Pamela Wallin latest to leave caucus
- 5.1 earthquake near Ottawa
- Mom and 5-year-old killed in Calgary
- Cocaine video & Toronto's mayor