McGill team wins prestigious $1 million global prize, dispute ensues
Sep 24, 2013 / 3:14 pm
MONTREAL - It was a moment of triumph for a group of McGill University students, who won a $1 million prize for social enterpreneurship handed out by Bill Clinton.
But the moment was more bitter than sweet for one student.
He was forced to watch from a distance, via Internet webcast, as his former allies rubbed shoulders with the former U.S. president.
Jakub Dzamba claims he was intellectually robbed.
Dzamba, a McGill University student, who is still involved in a dispute with the five-member MBA winning team, says it was sad to watch from afar as the group won the 2013 Hult competition grand prize for a nutrition project.
The Hult competition is described on its website as the world's largest student competition to solve social challenges, like helping to feed the urban poor. Winners use the prize money as seed capital, and get mentorship and advice from the international business community.
More than 10,000 students, representing more than 150 countries around the world, usually take part in the competition.
The winning project by the team from McGill's Desautels Faculty of Management involves the production, processing and promotion of insects for human consumption.
Team members received the award from the 42nd U.S. president in New York City on Monday night.
Dzamba, who was watching a webcast on his computer, says he worked with the team â€” and it was his slides and his presentation that were initially used when it won the semifinals.
But then, he says, they severed ties with him, took credit for his work, and haven't offered compensation.
"They ended up taking credit for my work and didn't compensate me in any way for my work," he said in an interview, saying he helped get the team to the finals.
He says a group of McGill associate deans and a commercialization officer got involved and decided that the team should pay him $5,300 for the work he had done. But there was a dispute over a release statement, which he called a "gag order," and it was never signed.
The 31-year-old Dzamba says he first started working on the idea of using insects for food at the University of Toronto in 2009 and got into a PhD program at McGill to work specifically on developing insect farming.
The university says it's "enormously proud" of the winning team, and other students hoping to change the world for the better.
In a statement, McGill vice-president Olivier Marcil said the university investigated the matter, proposed a resolution, and still hopes for a settlement.
Marcil said that in a university environment many ideas bubble up at the same time and, while there are conflicts sometimes, in many cases the ideas reinforce each other in helping others.
He said McGill has verified that the Hult presentation does not include any reference to the portable cricket farm designed by Dzamba.
The winning team also issued a statement on the dispute.
"As of mid-March 2013 we ceased using any of Jakub's contributions," it said. "We provided the university with the slide-deck of the final presentation for the Hult Prize and they have confirmed it does not include any reference to the portable cricket farm design described in the provisional patent application filed by the university (with Mr. Jakub Dzamba as sole inventor).
"It is our intention to compensate Jakub for his work as a past consultant and we are happy to give him credit for this contribution (though these contributions were not a factor in our regional win and were not included in our final presentation). We applaud any initiatives whose aim it is to alleviate world hunger and help make our world a better place."
Read more Business News
|QHR Technologies Inc||1.28||+0.09|
|Anavex Life Sciences||0.38||0.00|
|Copper Mountain Mining||1.54||-0.01|
This column is the last of three, for how to prove your personal injury claim. It is the piece de resistance of the trilogy, the Chuck Norris piece – the final say! As mentioned in the first two...
The bank manager just phoned and asked for full and immediate repayment of the line of credit because the latest, (and they were late!), financial statements showed continuing losses and falling sales...
Recently I recorded a video series for my keynote speaking business. It was called from Faith to Future. In one of the episodes, I talked about the concept of using hard work to get out of a difficul...
- Governments offers help to develop seal products in backing Atlantic industry
- Precision Drilling shares plummet as Alberta fund manager sells stake
- Most actively traded companies on the TSX, TSX Venture Exchange markets
- CIBC logs $836M profit in Q4, cautiously optimistic about next year
- Auto insurers urge holiday season refresher as young drivers return home
- Canadian Press NewsAlert: Canada creates 21,600 jobs, Nov. jobless rate 6.9%
- New CEO will help prepare Royal Bank for future, as divisions feel the pressure
- TD Bank Q4 profit rises to $1.62 billion, adjusted earnings up but miss estimate
- TSX drops 105 points amid mixed earnings from RBC, TD and CIBC, Fed concerns
- Loonie advances, traders look to Canadian, U.S. jobs data being released Friday
- Detroit bankruptcy judge follows up major bench ruling with written opinion, urges compromise
- Barrick Gold critic says Munk's departure will be a positive but concerns remain