Supreme Court confirms SNC-Lavalin's legal victory over Quebec regulator
Sep 5, 2013 / 12:51 pm
The Supreme Court of Canada has refused to overturn an appeal court ruling that allowed a an SNC-Lavalin corporate executive to provide details of a Quebec securities regulator's investigation to the engineering company's audit committee and external auditors.
The high court said Thursday that it won't hear l'Autorite des marches financiers' appeal of the Quebec Appeals Court ruling.
The provincial regulator had feared there was a risk of "collusion" if SNC-Lavalin (TSX:SNC) auditors were given details about its investigation into the scandal that has engulfed the engineering giant.
"We are pleased with the Supreme Court decision," SNC-Lavalin spokeswoman Leslie Quinton said in an email Thursday.
The AMF said it takes note of the decision.
"We knew that less then 10 per cent of that type of demand are accepted by that tribunal (the Supreme Court)," said spokesman Sylvain Theberge.
The AMF's review office â€” the Bureau de decision et de revision en valeurs mobilieres â€” had sided with SNC and rebuffed the regulator by authorizing SNC's audit committee and Deloitte & Touche to "review" all proposals for directing responses from the AMF for information and documents.
The regulator then took the decision of its review office to the Quebec courts, but the courts ruled against it.
Some former employees of the Montreal-based firm have been accused of ethical breaches, including $56 million of payments to unknown agents and $160 million in alleged bribes to the family of deposed Libyan dictator Moammar Gadhafi. Former CEO Pierre Duhaime has been charged with fraud involving about $22 million allegedly involving a super hospital in Montreal.
SNC-Lavalin had argued that the accounting firm would likely not approve 2012 financial statements if it wasn't informed about the nature of the AMF investigation.
Such a situation could create "confusion" in the markets, affect the company's share price and even lead to SNC suffering "dramatic damage," the company has previously said.
The regulatory body was ready to allow SNC to report the state of the investigation to its board and audit committee and to Deloitte, but without providing details.
The appeals court said the AMF provided no conclusive evidence of a risk of collusion, adding that the review bureau had made a reasoned decision.
Read more Business News
|QHR Technologies Inc||1.28||+0.09|
|Anavex Life Sciences||0.38||0.00|
|Copper Mountain Mining||1.54||-0.01|
This column is the last of three, for how to prove your personal injury claim. It is the piece de resistance of the trilogy, the Chuck Norris piece – the final say! As mentioned in the first two...
The bank manager just phoned and asked for full and immediate repayment of the line of credit because the latest, (and they were late!), financial statements showed continuing losses and falling sales...
Recently I recorded a video series for my keynote speaking business. It was called from Faith to Future. In one of the episodes, I talked about the concept of using hard work to get out of a difficul...
- Bruce Lee's iconic yellow jumpsuit fetches $100,000 at Hong Kong auction
- Spotify to allow users to create playlists on phones and tablets and listen to them for free
- US lurching from 'crisis to crisis,' politics influenced by money: Gary Doer
- Governments offers help to develop seal products in backing Atlantic industry
- Precision Drilling shares plummet as Alberta fund manager sells stake
- Most actively traded companies on the TSX, TSX Venture Exchange markets
- CIBC logs $836M profit in Q4, cautiously optimistic about next year
- Auto insurers urge holiday season refresher as young drivers return home
- Canadian Press NewsAlert: Canada creates 21,600 jobs, Nov. jobless rate 6.9%
- New CEO will help prepare Royal Bank for future, as divisions feel the pressure
- TD Bank Q4 profit rises to $1.62 billion, adjusted earnings up but miss estimate
- TSX drops 105 points amid mixed earnings from RBC, TD and CIBC, Fed concerns