Tuesday, September 23rd10.7°C
23284
22768

Tim Hudak defends math behind his Million Jobs Plan; economists not convinced

NIAGARA FALLS, Ont. - Tim Hudak was forced to defend his "Million Jobs Plan" Wednesday as a growing number of economists questioned the math behind the Ontario Progressive Conservative leader's promise, which is the centrepiece of his election platform.

Despite being hammered repeatedly on the issue, Hudak was adamant that the PC figures were right.

"I stand behind our numbers," he said at a furnace-making facility in Niagara Falls, Ont. "I simply believe that permanent tax reductions on job creators, more affordable energy is going to create jobs."

Hudak has promised a PC government would bring a million jobs to Ontario over the next eight years, although about half of those would be created through normal economic growth, regardless of which party is in government.

But first the Liberals, and then a number of prominent economists, including a former federal associate deputy minister of finance, have poked holes in Hudak's numbers, focusing in particular on the possibility that the Tories misinterpreted information from a Conference Board of Canada report commissioned by the PCs.

The report uses the term "person years of employment" in its projections, which some economists suggest the Tories have confused with permanent jobs, resulting in a vast overestimation of just how many new positions their plan for the province would create.

Mike Moffatt, an economist with Western University's Ivey School of Business, was among those who've penned columns criticizing what he calls the Tories' apparent misinterpretation.

"Most of their numbers are eight times multiplied," he said, explaining that the PCs appeared to have counted a person working in a single job over eight years as a separate job for every year of their plan.

"This in no way can be considered a million jobs plan...It's clear that the Tories misinterpreted these reports."

Hudak, however insisted his party's calculations were sound.

"We strongly disagree with that interpretation. I think that the economics is straightforward," he said. "Permanent reductions on taxes on job creators and on families mean permanent jobs."

Party officials later told reporters that they had used some data sources that dealt in person years of employment along with others that measured employment in different ways to come up with the jobs figures in their platform.

Hudak, meanwhile, tried to shift the focus on to his opponents, who he said were not being transparent about their plans for the province.

"We had two economists look at lower taxes on job creators and they came up with pretty much the same number," said Hudak. "I'll compare that to Andrea Horwath and the NDP, who think that taxes aren't high enough, and I'll also compare that with the fundamental dishonesty of the Liberals."

Premier Kathleen Wynne was quick to pounce on the controversy, saying it was clear the Tories had gotten their calculations "flat wrong."

"It's exceedingly rare for a platform to be revealed as a complete and utter fiction because the leader got the math wrong. So that's actually what we're dealing with right now," the Liberal leader said at a campaign stop in Markham, Ont.

"His plan won't create jobs, it will cost jobs. And we have been saying this, but it's very important that we recognize that the math, the arithmetic actually bears that out."

Christopher Worswick, an economics professor at Carleton University in Ottawa said it certainly seemed like the Tories were "double-counting."

"Normally when economists think about a policy change and its impact on employment, it might take several years for the full effect to hit the labour market but I think you would consider the total number of jobs created over that period," he said.

"You wouldn't count them up per year, which it sounds like they've done."

— With files from Keith Leslie.

The Canadian Press


Read more Business News

23392


Recent Trending




Today's Market
S&P TSX15151.37+22.37
S&P CDNX925.61-2.48
DJIA17169.86-2.82
Nasdaq4535.181+7.492
S&P 5001995.13+0.84
CDN Dollar0.9057+0.0001
Gold1223.20+5.2999
Oil91.50-0.91
Lumber333.00+6.40
Natural Gas3.936+0.028

 
Okanagan Companies
Pacific Safety0.17+0.01
Knighthawk0.01-0.005
QHR Technologies Inc1.24-0.03
Cantex0.05+0.01
Anavex Life Sciences0.205-0.0145
Metalex Ventures0.055+0.005
Russel Metals34.76-0.61
Copper Mountain Mining2.400.00
Colorado Resources0.160.00
ReliaBrand Inc0.0206-0.0043
Sunrise Resources Ltd0.02-0.005
Mission Ready Services0.27-0.02

 



23015

FEATURED Property
20720115466 South Perimeter Way
3 bedrooms 3 baths
$508,000
more details
image2image2image2
Click here to feature your property
Please wait... loading


Is this a fair offer from ICBC?

“Is this a fair offer from ICBC?”…. “How much should I settle for?”… “What is my claim worth?” These are just some of the questions I regularly get as...


Disruptive innovation

Last night I was privileged to be able to speak at the Greater Westside Board of Trade business awards dinner. Photo: ContributedI talked about Innovation and Collaboration which are two very interes...


Executors and their duties

There will be a time when you will need to decide who you should appoint as executor of your Will. As well, there may be a time when you will be asked by someone to act as the executor of his or her W...

_








Member of BC Press Council


22771