Tuesday, September 30th6.3°C
23366
22916

Jury still out on income splitting as new minister splits hairs on issue

OTTAWA - The Harper government has a new finance minister, but not necessarily new clarity on fulfilling its 2011 campaign promise on income splitting.

Since taking over the finance portfolio last Wednesday, Joe Oliver hasn't repeated his predecessor's concerns about an expensive tax cut that critics say will benefit only a minority of families, and favour those at the top of the income scale.

But he hasn't been unequivocal either, as Prime Minister Stephen Harper appeared to be last month when he said "income splitting has been a good policy for seniors in Canada, and it will also be a good policy for Canadian families."

Asked about it on his first day at his new post last week, Oliver appeared closer to Harper's apparent position than he was to Jim Flaherty's, although he did give a nod to his predecessor's call for a closer examination by stating that he was "going to be looking at the details."

Asked Tuesday whether he shares Flaherty's concerns that the pledge to allow families with dependent children to transfer up to $50,000 from the highest income earner to the lowest for tax purposes, Oliver was less than crystal clear.

"How the benefit will be distributed is obviously one of the issues that we look at, we look at the issue of fairness," he said.

"The point is we intend to lower taxes for families and when the next budget is announced we'll have the specific provisions. That's a decision for the next budget but the prime minister was very clear that income splitting can be a good policy for families."

Income splitting is a popular policy for the Conservative base because it is most helpful for traditional one-income families, where one spouse, usually the mother, stays home to take care of the children.

Employment Minister Jason Kenney is a strong proponent of keeping the promise and enacting a policy that he says "supports families who are investing in their kids."

He has also said that income splitting "doesn't benefit any particular family model; what it does is eliminate a form of unfairness."

But economists who have analyzed the Conservative plan says it will give the most benefit to families who need it the least, and no benefit at all to 85 per cent of Canadian households. And the program is costly at $2.7 billion a year.

An often-quoted C.D. Howe Institute analysis concluded that 40 per cent of the benefits will go to households with income of over $125,000. Meanwhile, single-parent families who tend to need it the most will be shut out. The program also does nothing for dual-income families where the couple have similar earnings.

Experts have said there are better ways of delivering tax relief to families, including increasing benefits under the Universal Child Care Benefit.

However, some have also noted that there are ways to tweak the income splitting proposal so that the benefits are more broadly distributed.

That would allow the Conservatives to say they have indeed brought in income splitting, just not the one they unveiled in the 2011 election campaign.

The Canadian Press


Read more Business News

23392


Recent Trending




Today's Market
S&P TSX14960.51-16.41
S&P CDNX909.29-3.47
DJIA17042.90-28.32
Nasdaq4493.39-12.462
S&P 5001972.29-5.51
CDN Dollar0.8924-0.0006
Gold1206.70-4.90
Oil90.16+0.40
Lumber333.20+0.30
Natural Gas4.126+0.005

 
Okanagan Companies
Pacific Safety0.13-0.005
Knighthawk0.01-0.005
QHR Technologies Inc1.26+0.03
Cantex0.065-0.025
Anavex Life Sciences0.184-0.001
Metalex Ventures0.0550.00
Russel Metals34.57+0.08
Copper Mountain Mining2.42-0.10
Colorado Resources0.165+0.015
ReliaBrand Inc0.019-0.001
Sunrise Resources Ltd0.065+0.045
Mission Ready Services0.32-0.02

 





FEATURED Property
2075463662 Peridot Court
5 bedrooms 4 baths
$785,000
more details
image2image2image2
Click here to feature your property
Please wait... loading


Power-save your way to a down payment

Part 2 of 2 to read Part 1, click here. 5. Dial down your vacations. New York is out. Maybe Buffalo. For West coast, maybe Seattle instead of Hawaii. Use sites like Airbnb (aribnb.ca) to find ch...


A wildly successful manufacturer

Niche food producer “Sweets from the Earth” thrives using innovation, uniqueness and an unwavering focus on quality. A neighbour’s stew turned Ilana Kadonoff off meat at the age of s...


Finding the smart money

Recently I had the privilege of working alongside André Voskuil, a local guru in the world of Alternative Financing. André has quite the reputation in the world of direct investments as ...

_








Member of BC Press Council


22814