LNG companies say BC tax too high
One of the first questions British Columbia's Finance Minister Mike de Jong was asked when he introduced the Liberal government's proposed Liquefied Natural Gas Income Tax as part of last week's budget, was how oil and gas companies would react to paying a tax that could top out at seven per cent.
"Of course, they want zero," he replied.
But de Jong pointed to a recent government-commissioned Ernst and Young survey that concluded B.C.'s all-in taxes — corporate, federal, provincial, municipal, carbon and the new LNG tax — put the province near or at the top of the heap compared to the tax regimes of potential competitors in Australia and the United States.
The B.C. plan "appears competitive relative to the existing frameworks in Australia and the five U.S. states," stated the 12-page review, with the proviso that their analysis does not take into account any "discretionary credits that a proponent may or may not be able to obtain."
The provincial budget last week revealed the government's proposed two-tiered LNG tax, which will be introduced as legislation in the fall. The first tier will be 1.5 per cent to be introduced at the start of production. The second tier, when introduced, could rise to seven per cent once the plant is running and capital costs have been deducted.
But no LNG revenues are in the government's three-year fiscal plan and the B.C. finance minister acknowledged tax dollars won't flow until plants are in production, which would be in 2018 at the earliest.
The Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers, which represents major oil and gas companies, was lukewarm towards the proposed tax regime. B.C. spokesman Geoff Morrison said the plan provides a framework but more work needs to be done on the rates.
A spokesman for LNG Canada, a proposed export facility near Kitimat that includes Shell Canada ( TSX:SHC), Korea Gas, Mitsubishi and PetroChina, said the company supports an LNG tax, but the seven per cent rate may be too high.
"We appreciate the government's commitment to flexibility on the two-tiered piece, " said Shell Canada spokesman David Williams. "It's clear that the rate has to be globally competitive. We're concerned that the top end of that range in the second tier will not achieve that level of global competitiveness."
Greg Kist, president of TransCanada Corp.'s (TSX:TRP) Pacific Northwest LNG, said his company, which has proposed a multibillion-dollar LNG facility near Prince Rupert, is looking for clarity from the government on the tax regime before making a final investment decision by the end of the year.
"For us, at this point in time, it's a situation where we want to understand the details," he said. "The LNG tax in and of itself is merely one piece of the fiscal framework we need to get clarity on before we can make a final investment decision."
The Liberals believe LNG is a trillion-dollar opportunity that could pay off the provincial debt, currently at almost $62 billion.
But industry analysts and the Opposition New Democrats say the Liberals are already a year behind schedule for a tax and royalty structure and in danger of losing the race.
Comments on this story are pre-moderated. Before they appear, comments are reviewed by moderators to ensure they meet our submission guidelines. Keep it clean, keep it civil, keep it truthful, stay on topic and be responsible. Comments are open and welcome for three days after the story is published. We reserve the right to close comments before then. Comments that appear on the site are not the opinion of Castanet, but only of the comment writer.
Read more Business News
- Small town reels after killingBC - 7:50 am
- Power out near Silver StarVernon / N. Okanagan - 9:00 am
- Firefighters injured in blazeCanada - 6:56 am
- Freight train derails, 30 deadWorld - 6:46 am
|QHR Technologies Inc||1.23||+0.02|
|Anavex Life Sciences||0.38||-0.005|
|Copper Mountain Mining||2.32||-0.06|
|Sunrise Resources Ltd||0.025||-0.005|
|Mission Ready Services||0.26||+0.01|
Our ability to live beyond our years has nothing to do with medical science; we will all live longer than our physical bodies, each of us will leave behind a personal legacy made up of our deeds, our ...
With all of the adventure activities I have done and still do, I wonder sometimes if the edge still exists. The systematic approach to learning a new adventure or extreme activity combined with the r...
How much time should you put into prospecting? The question is a bit of a puzzle. Ideally, there would be a reference book that lists, by industry, how much time you should invest in prospecting acti...