Mar 19, 2013 / 5:00 am
Unless you have been living under a rock, you’ve seen a young male wear a t-shirt with an inappropriate or adult-themed expression or joke written on it.
If you are prude, you probably wondered, “How is that person allowed to wear that, legally?”
Or maybe you are like me and thought, “That t-shirt is inappropriate, but it shouldn’t be illegal.”
Or maybe you just wondered, “How far can we go in our ‘freedom of expression’?” Well, if you thought this, you’re in luck: that is the topic of this week’s column.
Section 2(b) of the Charter allows for freedom of expression. But, what’s an “expression”? Well, for clarity, an expression is any means of communication that has content and expresses a meaning.
I hope that you don’t think there should be a bunch of limits on what we can say. That would be stupid (and very un-Canadian).
Thankfully, we are allowed to say and express ourselves however we want! It’s a Canadian value that we should be very proud of (and we should work hard to preserve). We can say or write anything! (…almost).
Obviously, there are limits... So, what are those limits?
Well, this part of the law is technical and complicated. Reason: we have to be careful with limiting our freedom of expression. It’s a slippery slope to take away someone’s right to express themselves.
But, without getting too technical, here is the basic law: expressions that are not allowed (i.e. against the law) are those that are really obscene or promote hatred or are threatening to someone. Here are a few examples…
Consider this case: R. v. Keegstra,  3 SCR 697. In this case, Mr. Keegstra was an Alberta high school social studies teacher. He was an idiot. He taught his students that Jews are “treacherous”, “sadistic”, “money-loving”, and “child killers”. He said a pile of other stupid things, too. Thankfully, he was charged with the Criminal Code offence of promoting hatred against a group of people (see section 319(2)).
In the case, Mr. Keegstra argued that he was allowed to make these statements because he had ‘freedom of expression’. That argument failed and Mr. Keegstra was criminally convicted of promoting hatred.
It is also illegal to make threatening comments to someone. This is referred to as ‘uttering threats’. See section 264.1 of the Criminal Code. Basically, this section makes it illegal to tell someone that you are going to hurt them or their property. We’ve all heard these sorts of comments made, whether in a pub or in a school. They are illegal…don’t say them.
Here’s the bottom-line: next time you see a young man wearing a t-shirt with a lame joke written on it, be happy that you live in Canada (and no one is telling him to take it off).
**The information contained in this column should not be treated by readers as legal advice and should not be relied on without detailed legal counsel being sought.
Read more Law Matters articles
- Give me back my money, now! Apr 9
- Consequences of a criminal record Apr 2
- Take it seriously: don’t use a Will kit Mar 26
- Watch your mouth! Mar 19
- Can police search your home or car? Mar 5
- Seeing dead people (and lawsuits) Feb 26
- Stalking your ex-girlfriend? Feb 19
- Hit and runs: know your rights Feb 12
- Arrested? Right to lawyer? Feb 5
- You're worth more alive than dead Jan 29
- Wear seatbelt or lose (big time!) Jan 22
- Sexual assault explained Jan 15
(Click for RSS instructions.)