Dec 22, 2012 / 11:24 am
America going over the fiscal cliff in January will likely be more of a bumpy toboggan slide for Canadians.
The prospects that U.S. lawmakers won't be able to find the goodwill to arrive at a compromise to prevent a $670-billion economic shock in 2013 dimmed considerably Friday after a vote failed and the House of Representatives headed home for the holidays.
The smart money bet that Republicans, despite their humbling loss in the November elections, couldn't bring themselves to swallow even the mildest tax hike needed to arrive at a deal with the Democrats.
U.S. President Obama called on lawmakers to pass legislation that will ensure everyone gives "a little bit in a sensible way." He said he still hopes a deal can be reached before Jan. 1.
But analysts note that even if Congress doesn't step up prior to Dec. 31, the world doesn't necessarily end on Jan. 1.
"This is not like a light switch that goes on or off," says Doug Porter, deputy chief economist with BMO Capital Markets.
"Things will change, but there are still all kinds of scenarios where the economic damage could be quite limited if policy-makers do respond quite quickly."
A detailed analysis by TD Bank calculates that if the fiscal hit lasts throughout 2013, the U.S. will lose three percentage points from growth, which means the economy would contract by about one per cent.
"In turn, Canada's economic turnout would be clipped by between one and 1.8 per cent," the report estimates. That's a significant haircut, but it also suggests the economy will likely be able to keep its head above water, if at nose level.
TD offers a proviso that economic behaviour has a human element, so not all the repercussions can be calculated to decimal points. The loss in confidence, panic even, could be make things much worse than economic models suggest.
"These estimates do not include the economic impact of financial volatility (stock markets) that would occur if there was a failure to reach a resolution, which raises the risk that Canada would follow the U.S. into a recession."
This week, Finance Minister Jim Flaherty said he would respond appropriately if the worst occurs, and he expressed confidence provincial finance ministers would follow suit as well.
But analysts note the fiscal cliff in the U.S. is a misnomer. A better term would be a "fiscal slope" because the fall off does not occur all at once. The longer it goes the worse it becomes, but the shorter the duration, the less the impact.
The oft-talked scenario is that after talks fail, President Barack Obama will quickly propose tax cuts for the middle class -- but not the affluent -- and reinstate a majority of the pre-existing spending levels.
That would give Republicans who had signed a no-taxes pledge cover to defend their actions, since they would have not voted to increase levies even on the super-rich.
Credit rating agencies downgraded U.S. debt and markets took a nosedive, but equities recovered just as quickly when Republicans and Democrats agreed to extend the limit so the government did not default on its loans. Economic output, however, remained positive, although the loss of confidence likely kept growth from being stronger.
The scenario changes if both sides dig in their heels and refuse to budge, economists say.
Read more Business News
|QHR Technologies Inc||1.19||+0.08|
|Anavex Life Sciences||0.38||+0.04|
|Copper Mountain Mining||1.55||0.00|
I saw your comment while reading your business article on Castanet regarding Harvey’s Hamburgers being the “Best Tasting Hamburgers". It is true, Harvey’s usually wins that awa...
Opportunities to Be Aware of This Year As the 2013 year is coming to an end, individuals should be mindful of year-end tax planning opportunities that will need to be implemented prior to December 31s...
When was the last time you thought about your mortgage? Most people take out a mortgage with their bank for five years and then forget about it. When you took out that mortgage did anyone discuss ot...
- US economy expands at 3.6 per cent rate in Q3 but business stockpiles drive half of the growth
- US jobless claims tumble 23,000 to 298,000, sign that companies are laying off fewer workers
- CIBC plans to open a branch at Pearson airport to draw in travellers, newcomers
- Transcontinental buying 74 Sun Media community papers in Quebec for $75 million
- RBC president and CEO Gordon Nixon to retire in Aug. 2014
- 'SpongeBob SquarePants,' other Nickelodeon programs come to China online viewers in Sohu deal
- Cost rises to $8.5B for North West refinery project northeast of Edmonton
- PBO even more optimistic than Flaherty of balanced budget in election year 2015
- Dollarama Q3 sales, profit increase as discount chain continues expansion
- Railroads say they'll offer health care benefits to same-sex spouses, 1 day after lawsuit
- WestJet November traffic grows, but load factor dips on higher capacity
- Saputo says it has 13.55 per cent of Australian diary it wants to acquire