Family blames Prince George's Simon Fraser Lodge for mother's death

Negligence alleged in death

Kelly Ashton was 62 when she died in Prince George hospice on Dec. 1. Her official cause of death was natural causes, but  her son Jason Keller and daughter Santaya Garnot are alleging their  mother’s death was wrongful.

Ashton, a long-term care  resident, fell and bumped her head twice on Nov. 9. But she was not seen  in person by a doctor until her children insisted she go to the  hospital on Nov. 11.

The siblings say her death was a result of negligence on behalf of Simon Fraser Lodge, a private long-term care facility contracted by Northern Health and run by Buron Healthcare Ltd. in Prince George. 

“She had dementia, but otherwise she wasn’t unhealthy,” said Garnot.

The siblings want to know why their mother wasn’t seen by a doctor in person or transferred to hospital earlier.

“When you have a loved one  with dementia, every moment of their time with you is precious,” said  Keller. “The lack of care our mother received at Simon Fraser Lodge  robbed us of the time we had left together.”

“Our mother passed away and we want to know what happened.”

While a representative from Buron  Healthcare, which operates Simon Fraser Lodge, declined to comment on  the particulars of Ashton’s case, citing privacy concerns, she noted  that they take all incidents seriously. Buron Healthcare’s  vice-president of operations, Michele Thomson, wrote that Buron  Healthcare is “always open to reviewing and updating policies and  procedures as required.” She noted the lodge has protocols for  preventing and dealing with falls in place.

Ashton was living with early-onset Alzheimer’s. She had two falls in a single day before she died.

On Nov. 9, she had been agitated and  wandering, according to an investigation by the long-term care facility.  Staff found her bruised and bleeding from a bump on her head around 4  a.m. in the common living room. 

Ashton couldn’t get up on her own from the  fall, but an assessment by a nurse found no concerns, according to an  internal investigation summary. Staff reassured her  son Keller she was alright when he came to check on her later in the  morning of Nov. 9.

That afternoon, Ashton  complained of head pain. She fell again in the early evening. Staff  found her on her hands and knees in front of a yellow caution sign  placed on the hallway floor around 6:20 p.m., the report said. There was  a second large and bruising bump on her head.

Facility staff again found no concerns in a  post-fall assessment, and when they consulted the doctor over the  phone, he did not recommend she go to hospital. Staff assured Keller and  his sister Garnot that their mother didn’t need further medical care  and would be seen by the doctor when he was in next. Garnot agreed to  the use of a restraint and a wheelchair to prevent future falls, a  solution recommended over the phone by the doctor.

But by Nov. 11, Keller said Ashton was “out  of it,” hunched over with her head tilted forward. She had not yet been  seen by the doctor in person. Her children insisted she go to the  hospital to be examined, and over the phone, the doctor authorized her  transfer to hospital via ambulance.

Shortly after she was admitted to the  University Hospital of Northern British Columbia in Prince George,  doctors diagnosed her with a concussion and two fractured vertebrae in  her neck.

Ashton received a neck brace and was stabilized in hospital, but died just weeks later in hospice on Dec. 1.

Meanwhile the family’s pursuit of answers  and accountability has been complicated by British Columbia’s wrongful  death laws, which limit their options for legal recourse. In the case of  wrongful deaths, families in B.C. can sue individuals and entities they  believe are at fault on their loved one’s behalf.

The Wills, Estates and Succession Act establishes that right but limits the damages families can seek to economic costs only.

And the Family Compensation Act specifies  those economic damages are limited to lost future income upon which  dependents relied and any funeral and burial costs associated with the  death.

The legislation does not allow families to  sue for their or their loved ones’ pain and suffering or seek punitive  damages if they allege gross negligence.

“What that basically says is that if you  are not a breadwinner, with young children, your life is worthless,”  said Michael-James Pennie, president of the BC Wrongful Death Law Reform  Society. “That means that anyone who does not meet that discriminatory  criteria has no legislative protection under the law.”

Learning that they have no legal avenue to  sue for wrongful death because their mother did not support them  financially has compounded the family’s grief, Garnot and Keller said.

Keller and Garnot said they plan to file  complaints with the Northern Health Patient Care Quality Office and the  College of Physicians and Surgeons of British Columbia against the  doctor who did not recommend Ashton go to hospital. They are mulling  other paths to justice, such as a Charter challenge, which would allege  their mother’s right to life, liberty and security of person was  violated by Simon Fraser Lodge and again by B.C.’s legislation.

More BC News