132587
59953

Penticton  

Judge: PIB road still 'public'

A roadway on private property on a First Nations reserve is still considered a “public place” if used by residents, according to a Penticton judge.

Darryn Allen Nelson was caught driving a motorcycle on Marron Valley Road through the PIB reserve in May 2017, against court order banning him from operating a motor vehicle on “any street, road, highway or other public place”.

He argued at a hearing earlier this summer that Marron Valley Road — which is primarily on private property held by a PIB member — is not a “public place” and outside the reach of the prohibition.

In a written judgement posted online this week Judge Gregory Koturbash disagreed.

“In the case at hand, the evidence clearly establishes that both reserve and non-reserve residents use Marron Valley Road with some regularity. The road is maintained by Argo Road Maintenance, has the usual signage of a public road, and connects Highway 3A and Green Mountain Road. Non-reserve people live along the road and use it to travel to and from their homes,” Koturbash wrote. “Marron Valley Road is a public place.”

“Even if only residents living on the reserve used the road, I still would have reached the same conclusion,” he continued. “The term public can and does include a limited group of people like reserve residents.”

Korturbash also dismissed Nelson’s secondary argument that he was not aware the road was a public space, ruling that being mistaken of the facts of a law is not a defence to a crime.

Nelson will be sentenced later this month.



More Penticton News

58538
Recent Trending
49792


56588




Send us your News Tips!


58362
Okanagan Oldies

Penticton SPCA Featured Pet

Scratch
Scratch Penticton SPCA >


54124


Castanet Proud Member of RTNDA Canada
59126
59599